Like most two-year-olds, my daughter cannot abide winter gear. I can’t know for sure why hats and mittens are so anathema to her, though I can speculate. From her reaction’s epic proportions, I surmise the stakes are pretty high, so maybe it’s an object permanence issue and she believes that when she puts the mittens on, her hands cease to exist. Or it could be that the mittens prevent her from cramming Goldfish into her mouth like it’s closing time at the cheddar cracker bar. Whatever the reason, my daughter, affectionately known in these parts as Terza, will not keep hats and mittens on. Not if I sing like Elmo, not if I ply her with cookies. Not for any reason.
For a while I made the rookie mistake of believing that I could solve the problem by buying the right stuff. I tried hats that velcro under the chin and hats with long yarn braids on the sides that you can tie in Houdini-proof knots and hats with bear ears and bunny ears and cat ears. I even tried a rainbow-colored, fleece jester hat that virtually screams, “THIS IS FUN! THE OPPOSITE OF TORTURE!” You can guess what my success rate was, based on the number of capital letters I just used.
Fail. Total fail.
I think her record time for keeping a hat on was about thirty seconds. Ditto with the mittens. She can’t manage to insert a spoonful of yogurt directly into her mouth half the time but man, can she get around knots.
So, we tried collaborative problem-solving. I ended up doing most of the heavy lifting, outlining the problem, proposing possible reasons why this problem existed (maybe the hat is too tight and constricting?), summing up her needs (to feel comfortable) and mine (to protect her from frostbite) and possible solutions (use a hood in lieu of a hat!), Her contribution? The word “No” and it’s many variations, including, “No I WON’T!” and “I no LIKE IT!” and even “No way Jose!”
Now, an aversion to winter gear is all very well and good when it’s forty degrees or thirty degrees, or hell, even twenty degrees. But when the temperatures get into the single digits, it’s a different story. When it gets so cold that scientists coin special phrases to describe the weather–phrases that involve the noun “vortex”—I can’t tolerate Terza’s intolerance of winter gear. Not when she and I have a daily drop-off walk that takes twenty minutes. We do more trekking than the Greely expedition, and if I learned anything from watching that harrowing documentary, it’s: if you don’t come prepared to the Arctic, you’ll all end up eating each other.
“Just wait until she gets cold enough,” everyone likes to say, “She’ll put those hat and gloves on then.”
It is sound reasoning, to be sure. Logical. It is however, utter horse-crap, at least in my daughter’s case. I know because I tested the theory. The temperature dropped lower and lower, until it was hovering at five degrees, just above zero, and I told myself, “Now, we will hit her breaking point, She’ll be so cold, she’ll immediately beg for hat and mittens.” We walked outside, and even though I was wearing leather gloves and a wool hat with a down hood pulled up over my head, my hands and ears went numb within a minute.
Not only would Terza not wear her mittens, she baited me into shedding my gloves every two blocks so that I could attempt to yank hers back on again. As soon as I’d put my gloves back on and secure the wind cover onto the stroller, I’d see she’d already pulled off her mittens again—the allegedly “toddler-proof” mittens which zip up the sides and velcro closed at the wrist. After a few rounds of this Sisyphesean game, I decided to just give up on the mittens, and attempted to persuade her—all while standing on the street corner, fighting the gale-force winds—to please, PLEASE, tuck her hands into the cozy, criminally-fluffy stroller sleeping bag I’d zipped her lower half into. What I got was her default response: “NEVER!” And screaming, of course. Endless screaming, which wasn’t surprising considering her fingers were probably shooting with pain from the unbearable cold.
That is when I realized that the people who told me she’d wear the gloves when she got cold enough do not know toddlers. Toddlers don’t have a terrific grasp on cause and effect. The logic of “If you don’t wear your mittens, your fingers will be cold” is very persuasive to a five- or seven- or ten-year-old, but totally meaningless to most two-year-olds.
Terza was obviously thinking “It is freezing!” and “I deplore mittens” but could not understand that these two things were correlated in any way. So, she wailed and wailed and looked at me like, “For God’s sake, woman, I’m freezing to death out here. Do something! And while you’re at it, get those hideous mittens out of my face!”
It’s enough to make a girl dream of living in Tampa.
“So let her get frostbite!” you might say. But think for a second about what an imposition a case of frostbite would be on my already hectic schedule.
Look, I get it. There are some things—many things—beyond our control as parents. Some behaviors that can not be modified despite bribes, punishments, distraction techniques, and the force of reason. One of the hardest things I’ve learned to do as a parent is accept this and just let it go, let the natural consequences unfold.
And then, other times, I don’t let go. Other times, I resort to duct tape.
In a moment of inspiration, I strolled screaming, kicking, totally indignant Terza into the nearest hardware store, bought a roll of duct tape and duct-taped those mittens right onto the sleeve of her jacket. Then, when she was helpless to stop me, I yanked the red, fleece-lined, bear-eared hat on her head. Cruel, awful, overbearing me. She was warm, did not require medical attention, and retained the use of all her digits.
Sometimes the only choice you have as a parent is between crappy and slightly less crappy. Between screaming with frostbite and screaming without frostbite. So you choose the lesser of two crappys. And you wait for spring. ◆
Nicole C. Kear is the author of the memoir Now I See You (St. Martin’s, June ‘14) and the mom behind the blog, A Mom Amok. You can find more info about her and her work at nicolekear.com.